[The evaluation of HepatoConsult, a hepatological expert system--the initial results and trends]

HepatoConsult (HC) is a medical expert system, based on the expert system building block D3, designed to aid in the diagnosis of liver and biliary tract disease. It was the aim of this study to evaluate its diagnostic competence in clinical cases prospectively.

The diagnostic accuracy of HC was tested prospectively in 106 consecutive patients with the main diagnosis of liver disease. 57 were ambulant, 49 were in-patients. The data were obtained and stored at defined phases of the diagnosis. The diagnoses put forward by HC were compared with the final clinical diagnosis and, on the basis of the data, checked for plausibility by four experienced physicians.

After history taking and physical examination HC put forward the main diagnosis, as established by the doctors in charge, in 60% of patients. After addition of the results of basic laboratory tests and sonography, HC provided the correct diagnosis in 85% and, after inclusion of all the findings, in 93%. In almost all cases HC put forward diagnoses that were, on the basis of the supplied data, considered correct by the four physicians experienced in liver disease. In 56% of cases HC provided more differentiated diagnoses or items in the differential diagnosis than the attending doctors. In the opinion of the four assessors HC had not put forward any seriously wrong diagnoses.

HC can be useful in solving diagnostic problems and thus in ensuring the quality of medical diagnoses.