The impact of semantic memory impairment on spelling: evidence from semantic dementia

We assessed spelling and reading abilities in 14 patients with semantic dementia (with varying degrees of semantic impairment) and 24 matched controls, using spelling-to-dictation and single-word reading tests which manipulated regularity of the correspondences between spelling and sound, and word frequency. All of the patients exhibited spelling and reading deficits, except at the very earliest stages of disease. Longitudinal study of seven of the patients revealed further deterioration in spelling, reading, and semantic memory. The performance of both subject groups on both spelling and reading was affected by regularity and word frequency, but these effects were substantially larger for the patients. Spelling of words with exceptional (or more precisely, unpredictable) sound-to-spelling correspondences was most impaired, and the majority of errors were phonologically plausible renderings of the target words. Reading of low frequency words with exceptional spelling-to-sound correspondences was also significantly impaired. The spelling and reading deficits were correlated with, and in our interpretation are attributed to, the semantic impairment.