The outcome of research training during surgical residency

Graduates of a university surgical residency program were surveyed to identify the timing of specialty selection and the impact that studying in a research laboratory had on subsequent acceptance into a fellowship program.

Between 1975 and 1990, 86 residents completed general surgery training at UCLA Medical Center. A survey was sent to all graduates to determine the focus of their previous laboratory research and when they selected their eventual surgical specialty. Responses were received from 67 of the 86 graduates (78%).

Forty-eight of the sixty-seven respondents (72%) took one or more years of surgical research during residency. Postresidency fellowship training was selected by 55 of 67 (82%); 50 applied to fewer than five programs; 49 of 55 (89%) received one of their top three choices. Twenty-seven of the sixty-seven residents pursued an academic career (40%). Residents who performed at least 2 years of research were more likely to become academicians (53%) than residents who did 1 year or less of research (22%). Only 39 of 67 residents (58%) had selected a specialty after 2 years of clinical training; 28 more made the selection after the third clinical year. All residents interested in cardiac surgery (n = 18) or plastic surgery (n = 4) prior to research were accepted into fellowships in those specialities, whereas only 37% of those who had an interest in other fields pursued the same specialty (P < 0.0001). Residents performing research in general surgery (n = 9), surgical oncology (n = 18), cardiac surgery (n = 14), and plastic surgery (n = 3) were more likely to practice in that specialty than those doing research in other specialty laboratories.

General surgery residents performing research in a specialty laboratory are likely to pursue fellowship training relating to that field. Those who select a career in cardiac or plastic surgery prior to research are most likely to enter into these fields as their eventual specialty. Residents who perform 2 or more years of laboratory research publish more papers and often pursue an academic career.