Chlorine stable isotopes: a comparison of dual inlet and thermal ionization mass spectrometric measurements

Chlorine stable isotope ratios, 37Cl/35Cl, currently are measured using dual-inlet and thermal-ionization mass spectrometry. These two different analytical techniques, however, have never been cross calibrated. A set of samples with chlorine stable isotope delta values ranging from -4.4 to +0.3 % relative to standard mean ocean water chloride has been analyzed using both of these techniques. Our data show that both techniques can yield similar results within analytical uncertainty. CsCl thermal ionization data are extremely sensitive to the amount of chlorine being measured and cannot be used to determine absolute ratios without an independent means of correcting for machine-induced mass fractionation. As long as standards and samples are of equivalent size, however, the differences between samples measured by thermal ionization remain constant Dual inlet stable isotope mass spectrometry is suited best for samples of > 10 micromol Cl, yielding chlorine stable isotope data with < or =0.1% reproducibilities (2sigma). Thermal ionization mass spectrometry easily accommodates samples of approximately0.1-0.3 micromol Cl, with achievable uncertainties of < or =0.2% (2sigma).