Related Experiment Video
Updated: Aug 10, 2026

Endaural Endoscopic Atticoantrotomy (Retrograde Mastoidectomy) using a Constant Suction Bone-drilling Technique
Published on: May 23, 2021
Rate of persistent perforation after elective tympanostomy tube removal in pediatric patients
E J Lentsch1, S Goudy, T M Ganzel
1Department of Surgery, Division of Otolaryngology, University of Louisville School of Medicine, 40292, Louisville, KY, USA.
Insights
Persistent perforations after tympanostomy tube removal occur in 11% of cases. Factors like longer tube duration and specific tube types increase this risk.
Area of Science:
- Otolaryngology
- Pediatric Surgery
- Medical Device Research
Background:
- Tympanostomy tubes are commonly used to treat otitis media in children.
- Persistent tympanic membrane perforations can result from tube removal.
- Understanding risk factors is crucial for optimizing surgical outcomes.
Purpose of the Study:
- To determine the incidence of persistent perforations after elective tympanostomy tube removal in children.
- To identify factors influencing perforation rates, including tube type and duration of intubation.
Main Methods:
- Retrospective chart analysis of 201 children undergoing 273 elective tympanostomy tube removals.
- Data collected included patient age, tube type, duration of intubation, and presence of granulation tissue.
- Persistent perforation defined as eardrum not healed within 3 months post-removal.
Main Results:
- An overall persistent perforation rate of 11% was observed.
- Paparella II tubes (22%) and durations >3 years (15%) were associated with higher perforation rates.
- Collar Bobbin tubes had no associated perforations.
Conclusions:
- The rate of persistent perforation following elective tympanostomy tube removal is significant.
- Longer intubation duration (>3 years) and use of Paparella II tubes are risk factors.
- Further research into tube materials and surgical techniques may reduce perforation rates.
Abstract:
This study was performed to determine the rate of persistent perforations according to age, tube type and duration of intubation in children who underwent elective tympanostomy tube removal. Our retrospective analysis of hospital and clinic charts included all patients who underwent elective tube removal from July 1995 to December 1997 at our institution. Information from the chart review included patient age at time of tube removal, type of tube removed, duration of intubation, presence of granulation tissue/polyps, and concomitant paper patch placement. The outcome of each surgical removal was determined by examining follow-up clinic charts. A patient was deemed to have a persistent perforation if the eardrum had not adequately healed within 3 months after surgery. Data on 201 patients were gathered. These patients had 273 tube removals. Eleven percent of ears (29/273) had persistent perforations. According to tube type, no perforations (0/48) occurred with Collar Bobbin tubes, 6% (3/50) with Tytan tubes, 7% (3/44) with Duravent tubes, and 22% (16/74) with Paparella II tubes. Three percent (3/101) of tubes in place for <3 years and 15% (26/172) of tubes in place for >3 years showed persistent perforations after removal. Ears with granulation polyps had a 9% (18/203) rate of perforations, whereas those without granulation polyps had a 16% (11/70) rate of perforations. Forty percent (4/10) of ears were treated with paper patches at the time of tube removal showed persistent perforations. Our data indicate that the rate of persistent perforation (11%) after elective tympanostomy tube removal is high. The factors associated with higher rates of persistent perforation (P<0.05) include duration of intubation >3 years prior to removal and the use of long-term Paparella II tubes.
Related Concept Videos
Tracheostomy: Procedure and Tubes
Tracheostomy tubes can be made of semiflexible plastic (polyurethane or silicone), rigid plastic, or metal, and they come in...
Suctioning the Nasopharyngeal Airway
Equipment Required
Esophageal Perforation-I: Introduction
The location of esophageal perforation can vary, occurring anywhere along the esophagus.
Esophageal Perforation-II: Clinical Manifestations and Management
Clinical Manifestations:

