Tensile characteristics of ten commercial acrylic bone cements

The mechanical properties of acrylic bone cement, used in orthopedic surgery, are very influential in determining successful long-term stability of a prosthesis. A large number of commercial formulations are available, differing in chemical composition and physical properties of both powder and monomer constituents. In this study, the static and dynamic tensile characteristics of a number of the most commonly used bone cements (Palacos R, Simplex P, CMW 1 & 3, Sulfix-60, Zimmer Dough), along with some newer formulations (Endurance, Duracem 3, Osteobondtrade mark and Boneloc), have been investigated under the same testing regimes. Testing was performed in air at room temperature. Significant differences in both static and fatigue properties were found between the various bone cements. Tensile tests revealed that Palacos R, Sulfix-60, and Simplex P had the highest values of ultimate tensile strength, closely followed by CMW 3, while Zimmer Dough cement had the lowest strength. Fatigue testing was performed under stress control, using sinusoidal loading in tension-tension, with an upper stress level of 22MPa. The two outstanding cements when tested in these cyclic conditions were Simplex P and Palacos R, with the highest values of Weibull median cycles to failure. Boneloc bone cement demonstrated the lowest cycles to failure. While the testing regimes were not designed to replicate exact conditions experienced by the bone cement mantle in vivo, there was a correlation between these results and clinical outcome.