Surface morphology and wear mechanisms of four clinically relevant biomaterials after hip simulator testing

The surfaces of worn components hold clues to the underlying wear mechanisms. Previous evidence suggested that the absolute wear rates of acetabular components in a hip simulator were related to mechanical behavior; we hypothesized that the surface morphology of the liners might also be sensitive to mechanical properties. A noncontact, three-dimensional surface topography measurement system based on white light interferometry was used to quantify the surface morphology of ultra-high molecular weight polyethylene, polytetrafluoroethylene, high-density polyethylene, and polyacetal liners, and their corresponding femoral heads, after 3 million cycles in a multi-directional hip simulator. Comparisons were made with the fatigue soaked and control (as machined) components. Statistically significant power law relationships were observed between the arithmetic mean surface roughness (R(a)) of the worn acetabular liners and the volumetric wear rate in the hip simulator (p < 0.01, r(2) = 0.52). Significant relationships were also observed between R(a) and the elastic and large deformation mechanical behavior of the liner materials, measured directly from the wear-tested liners using the small punch test (p < 0.01, r(2) = 0.54-0.81). The results support the hypothesis that wear mechanisms of acetabular liners during hip simulator testing are related to surface morphology in conjunction with the mechanical behavior of the polymeric materials.