The phylogenetic utility of the codon-degeneracy model

The codon-degeneracy model (CDM) predicts relative frequencies of substitution for any set of homologous protein-coding DNA sequences based on patterns of nucleotide degeneracy, codon composition, and the assumption of selective neutrality. However, at present, the CDM is reliant on outside estimates of transition bias. A new method by which the power of the CDM can be used to find a synonymous transition bias that is optimal for any given phylogenetic tree topology is presented. An example is illustrated that utilizes optimized transition biases to generate CDM GF-scores for every possible phylogenetic tree for pocket gophers of the genus Orthogeomys. The resulting distribution of CDM GF-scores is compared and contrasted with the results of maximum parsimony and maximum likelihood methods. Although convergence on a single tree topology by the CDM and another method indicates greater support for that particular tree, the value of CDM GF-score as the sole optimality criterion for phylogeny reconstruction remains to be determined. It is clear, however, that the a priori estimation of an optimum transition bias from codon composition has a direct application to differentiating between alternative trees.