Incomplete penetrance of MHC susceptibility genes: prospective analysis of polygenic MHC-determined traits

We propose an approach to understanding incomplete penetrance of disease susceptibility genes as a method of studying the underlying mechanisms of polygenic diseases. Incomplete penetrance is the failure of genetically susceptible individuals to exhibit a trait. We define as baseline penetrance that which occurs in genetically identical (monozygotic) twins of an index subject with a major histocompatibility complex (MHC)-associated disease or trait. We consider two mechanisms for incomplete baseline penetrance: an extrinsic (environmental) trigger and an intrinsic stochastic, gene-associated process. The latter can be detected for dominant expression because susceptibility genes in homozygotes (with their two intrinsic triggers) will be up to twice as frequently penetrant as those in heterozygotes. The extent of MHC and non-MHC gene contribution determines differences between baseline penetrance and apparent penetrance in MHC-identical sib pairs, sib pairs in general and MHC-identical unrelated individuals. Inheritance patterns in families do not reveal modes of inheritance of incompletely penetrant polygenic MHC-determined traits. A method is proposed to study such traits prospectively in persons presumed to be homozygous, heterozygous or non-carrying for susceptibility genes by determining trait expression in homozygotes, heterozygotes or non-carriers of trait-associated conserved extended MHC haplotypes. The method provides direct estimates of apparent penetrance rates, modes of genetic determination, and, if the trait is dominant, the origin of penetrance. When applied to dominant MHC susceptibility gene-determined immunoglobulin deficiencies in two populations, the ratios of affected haplotype homozygotes to heterozygotes near 2.0 were consistent with an intrinsic mechanism for baseline penetrance acting on the MHC susceptibility genes.