Related Experiment Videos
Healing madness and despair through meeting
1Faculty, Department of Psychiatry, Einstein College of Medicine, New York, NY 10010, USA.
American Journal of Psychotherapy
|January 11, 2000
Summary
Existential suffering presents a dilemma: introspection risks despair, while avoiding it risks instinctual urges. Western psychology
Area of Science:
- Psychology
- Philosophy
- Existentialism
Background:
- Psychoanalytic self-examination presents a dilemma: avoiding introspection risks instinctual urges, while intense self-reflection may lead to despair.
- Western psychology's view of humans as encapsulated consciousness contributes to difficulties in treating madness and despair.
Purpose of the Study:
- To explore the existential dilemma posed by psychoanalytic self-examination.
- To critique the Western psychological perspective of encapsulated consciousness.
- To propose authentic dialogue as a therapeutic tool.
Main Methods:
- Conceptual analysis of existential and psychoanalytic perspectives.
- Critique of Western psychological paradigms.
- Application of Martin Buber's philosophy of authentic dialogue.
- Use of clinical material to illustrate therapeutic potential.
Main Results:
- The encapsulated consciousness model in Western psychology creates a dilemma in self-examination, potentially leading to despair or instinct-driven behavior.
- Martin Buber's concept of authentic dialogue offers a framework to overcome this separation.
Conclusions:
- Authentic dialogue can bridge the gap between the sufferer and the healer, offering a path beyond the existential dilemma.
- A relational, rather than encapsulated, view of consciousness is crucial for addressing profound psychological suffering.