A validated finite element method study of orthodontic tooth movement in the human subject

The aim of the study was to develop a 3D computer model of the movement of a maxillary incisor tooth when subjected to an orthodontic load. A novel method was to be developed to directly and accurately measure orthodontic tooth movement in a group of human volunteers. This was to be used to validate the finite element-based computer model. The design took the form of a prospective experiment at a laboratory at the University of Wales in 1996/7. A laser apparatus was used to sample tooth movement every 0.01 seconds over a 1-minute cycle for 10 healthy volunteers, whilst a constant 0.39 N load was applied. This process was repeated on eight separate occasions and the most consistent five readings taken for each subject. Data were used to calculate the physical properties of the periodontal ligament (PDL). The data gleaned by this method were used to validate the 3D FEM model. This was formed of 15,000 four-noded tetrahedral elements. Tooth displacements ranged from 0.012 to 0.133 mm. An appropriate elastic modulus of 1 N/mm(2) and Poisson's Ratio of 0.45 was derived for the PDL. Strain analysis, using the model, suggested that a maximum PDL strain of 4.77 x 10(-3) was recorded at the alveolar crest, while the largest apical strain recorded was 1.55 x 10(-3). The maximum strains recorded in the surrounding alveolar bone were 35 times less than for the PDL. A novel method for direct measurement of PDL physical properties in the human subject has been developed. The validated FEM model lends further evidence that the PDL is the main mediator of orthodontic tooth movement.