Effects of ionization mode on charge-site-remote and related fragmentation reactions of long-chain quaternary...

Comparison of collisionally activated fragment spectra of long-chain quaternary ammonium ions, formed by liquid-assisted secondary ion mass spectrometry (LSIMS) and electrospray ionization (ESI), shows the latter are dominated by radical cations while the former yield mainly even-electron charge-site-remote (CSR) fragments, similar to the report for different precursors by Cheng et al., J. Am. Soc. Mass Spectrom. 1998, 9, 840. Here, mixed-site fragmentation products (formal loss of a radical directly bonded to the nitrogen plus a radical derived from the long chain) are of comparable importance for both ionization techniques. These observations are difficult to understand if the CSR ions are formed by a concerted rearrangement-elimination reaction, since precollision internal energies of the ESI ions are much lower than those of the ions from LSIMS. Alternatively, if one discards the concerted mechanism for high-energy CA, and assumes that the even-electron fragments are predominantly formed via homolytic bond cleavage, the colder radical cations from ESI survive to the detector while the more energized counterparts from LSIMS preferentially lose a hydrogen atom to yield the CSR ions, as proposed by Wysocki and Ross (Int. J. Mass Spectrom. Ion Processes 1991, 104, 179). The present work also attempts to reconcile discrepancies involving critical energies and known structures for neutral fragments.