Inhaled naphthalene causes dose dependent Clara cell cytotoxicity in mice but not in rats

Current OSHA standards for naphthalene exposure are set at 10 ppm (time-weighted average) with a standard threshold exposure concentration of 15 ppm. While several studies have thoroughly delineated the time course and dose response of injury by naphthalene administered ip, the pattern and severity of injury by inhalation exposure are unknown. These studies compare the regiospecific and dose-dependent cytotoxicity of naphthalene after inhalation exposure. Mice and rats were exposed for 4 h to naphthalene vapor at concentrations of 0-110 ppm. In rats, no injury was observed in the lung epithelium at exposure concentrations up to 100 ppm. Exposures as low as 2 ppm produced proximal airway injury in mice, with increased severity in a concentration-dependent fashion up to 75 ppm. Terminal airways of exposed mice exhibited little or no injury at low concentrations (1-3 ppm). Exposures of 8.5 ppm or higher were required to produce injury to Clara cells in the terminal airways. In contrast, administration of naphthalene (300 mg/kg) extended the injury pattern toward the lobar bronchus. We conclude (1) the pattern of injury to naphthalene is highly dependent on the route of exposure, (2) lung injury to inhaled naphthalene is species dependent, and (3) Clara cells of mouse airways are exquisitely sensitive to inhaled naphthalene at concentrations well below the current OSHA standard for human exposure.