Teaching a simple reading vocabulary to retarded children: effectiveness of fading and nonfading procedures

Four equated groups of moderately retarded children were trained on a simple eight-word vocabulary, each under a different experimental condition. In the standard condition a printed work was repeatedly paired with a pictured representation. In the faded condition the same procedure was used except that the picture was gradually faded-out over trials. A mixed condition had, on alternate trials, either work-and-picture or word alone, while on alternate trials a control condition had either picture alone or word alone. On immediate and delayed tests of vocabulary learning, subject showed large differences in reading performance with these methods. The order of efficiency of conditions was faded, mixed, standard, and control. Several theoretical interpretations of the superiority of fading were considered. The conclusion favored was that the fading procedure was best because it increased the attention-value of the words in relation to the faded pictures, without sacrificing the superior associative effects of noncontingent pairings of words and pictures.