Finite element analysis (FEA) as a model to predict effects of farriery on the equine hoof

A finite element (FE) hoof capsule was built as a small, symmetrical forelimb hoof on IDEAS* as a model for calculation and visualisation of stress and displacement of the equine hoof capsule. The model's loading was performed according to the suspension of the coffin bone within the hoof wall (pulling force) and over the sole and frog (compressing force) with a total of 3000 N. Restraints of the model's ground nodes and surface wall nodes were defined for simulation of 4 shoeing situations: a regular horseshoe, a horseshoe with a toe clip, a horseshoe with regular side clips and a horseshoe with a toe clip and more caudally-placed side clips, all fixed to the hoof capsule with 3 nails on each side and each calculated in a tense and a loose nailed condition. Von Mises stresses were taken ranging from 1.22 N/mm2 in the weightbearing border of the side clip shoe fixed loosely to the capsule up to 16.67 N/mm2 in the hoof horn material surrounding the third nail. Further high stress zones were calculated in the proximal dorsal wall, the distal heel and the lateral hoof wall. Displacement values were taken showing movements of hoof wall, sole and frog according to the shoeing conditions. Maximal displacement was calculated in the hoof capsule shod with a regular horseshoe without a clip. Minimal displacement was found in the capsule with a toe clip and 2 side clips placed behind the 3rd nail. All models showed higher displacements when calculated with a loose nail fixation. Validation of the detailed features of the models is not yet possible. Finite element analysis (FEA) can be used practically to predict influences of various farrier techniques on the equine hoof in order to avoid possible harm to horses' feet in field studies.