Related Experiment Videos
A child with earache. Are antibiotics the best treatment?
1Centre for General Practice, University of Queensland. C.DelMar@cgp.uq.edu.au
Insights
For acute otitis media, antibiotics offer minimal pain relief but cause side effects. Balancing harms and benefits suggests fewer children should receive antibiotics for this common ear infection.
Area of Science:
- Pediatrics
- Otolaryngology
- Evidence-Based Medicine
Background:
- Conventional acute otitis media management prioritizes microbiological cure with antibiotics over pain relief.
- This approach often overlooks the patient's experience of pain and potential adverse effects.
Observation:
- A case study of a three-year-old child with uncomplicated AOM is presented.
- An evidence-based approach to managing AOM is explored, challenging traditional methods.
Findings:
- A Cochrane review indicates antibiotic benefits for AOM (reduced pain beyond 24 hours) are offset by adverse events like gastrointestinal issues and rashes.
- Evidence suggests rare complications are infrequent whether antibiotics are used or not for AOM.
Implications:
- Considering the balance of harms and benefits suggests reducing antibiotic prescriptions for AOM in children.
- This evidence-based perspective advocates for a more judicious use of antibiotics in pediatric AOM management.
Background:
Conventional management of acute otitis media, deduced from pathophysiology, embodies scant regard to analgesia, but concentrates on the microbiological cure by the use of antibiotics.
Objective:
A commonly encountered case of uncomplicated acute otitis media in a child of three is presented. An evidence based approach to management is offered.
Results:
The search for empirical evidence of patient relevant benefits and harms challenges the conventional approach. A Cochrane review of the literature on the use of antibiotics for acute otitis media shows that the benefits of antibiotic use (reduced pain in those children who go on to suffer pain beyond 24 hours) are offset by adverse events from the antibiotics themselves (gastrointestinal symptoms and rashes). There is insufficient information to be sure about rare complications of not using antibiotics as well using them, but it seems that in either case, catastrophe is very rare.
Discussion:
Thinking in terms of a balance of harms and benefits would result in a decreased proportion of children prescribed antibiotics for acute otitis media.