Vertical and nonvertical participation by sulfur, selenium, and tellurium

The mechanism of stabilization of positive charge on carbon by sulfur, selenium, or tellurium at the beta-position has been investigated kinetically, by measurement of rate enhancements, and structurally, by variation of the bond strength to the leaving group. Stabilization can occur either nonvertically with formation of a bridged intermediate or vertically through hyperconjugation within an open carbocation. We observed large rate enhancements (10(5) for S, 10(6) for Se) in 97% aqueous trifluoroethanol with trifluoroacetate as the leaving group. These enhancements are consistent with either mechanism. Product structures also are consistent with either mechanism. Nine crystal structures revealed that the bond to the leaving group (C-O) is lengthened by the presence of S or Se at the beta-position, in proportion to the basicity of the leaving group. This lengthening is not accompanied by angle distortions expected for the bridging mechanism. The crystallographic data support vertical (hyperconjugative) character along the reaction coordinate, more so for selenium than sulfur.