Insertion of X-ray structures of proteins in membranes

Few structures of membrane proteins are known and their relationships with the membrane are unclear. In a previous report, 20 X-ray structures of transmembrane proteins were analyzed in silico for their orientation in a 36A-thick membrane [J. Mol. Graph. Model. 20 (2001) 235]. In this paper, we use the same approach to analyze how the insertion of the X-ray structures varies with the bilayer thickness. The protein structures are kept constant and, at each membrane thickness, the protein is allowed to tilt and rotate in order to accommodate at their best. The conditions are said to be optimal when the energy of insertion is minimal. The results show that most helix bundles require thicker membranes than porin barrels. Moreover, in a few instances, the ideal membrane thickness is unrealistic with respect to natural membranes supporting that the X-ray structure requires adaptation to stabilize in membrane. For instance, the squalene cyclase could adapt by bending the side chains of its ring of lysine and arginine in order to increase the hydrophobic surface in contact with membranes. We analyzed the distribution of amino acids in the water, interface and acyl chain layers of the membrane and compared with the literature.