Fertility assessment through heterospermic insemination of flow-sorted sperm in cattle

The ability to assess fertility of bovine sperm accurately and rapidly would be very useful for research and applications to the cattle industry. Sperm motility and other in vitro tests of sperm normality are only partially correlated with fertility, and lengthy breeding trials are expensive and time consuming. Heterospermic insemination by mixing sperm from more than one male provides an in vivo method to assess relative fertility among bulls that can be economical and rapid. Sperm that had been flow-sorted and cryopreserved from four groups of four bulls were inseminated in all combinations of three bulls within groups into nonsuperovulated heifers or superovulated heifers. Embryos were collected nonsurgically between d 13.5 and 20 following estrus and evaluated for paternity by genotyping. Following determination of paternity, a heterospermic index was created for each bull using a maximum likelihood function. These indices ranged from 0.22 +/- 0.15 to 2.43 +/- 0.43 (mean = 1.00, with a higher value indicative of greater fertility). In all four groups, either the high- or low-fertility bull was identified (P < 0.05) using a total of 25 to 36 genotypable embryos from nonsuperovulated heifers. The heterospermic rankings of bulls were similar for single and superovulated heifers for one group of bulls, but dissimilar for a second group. Heterospermic insemination followed by genotyping of embryos proved to be efficacious for rapidly ranking fertility of flow-sorted sperm from bulls when females were not superovulated, but results were less clear when females were superovulated.