Evaluation of thyroid stimulating hormone (TSH) alone as a first-line thyroid function test (TFT) in Papua New Guinea

In the Port Moresby General Hospital, the Chemical Pathology Department assays both thyroid stimulating hormone (TSH) and free thyroxine (FT4) on all requests for a thyroid function test (TFT). The cost of assaying both tests is obviously higher than either test alone. In order to minimize the cost of a TFT we aimed to determine if TSH or FT4 alone as a first-line test would be adequate in assessing the thyroid hormone status of patients. We analyzed TFT records from January 1996 to May 2000 in the Port Moresby General Hospital. A total of 3089 TSH and 2867 FT4 were assayed at an annual reagent cost of Papua New Guinea kina 14,500. When TSH alone is used as a first-line test at the Port Moresby General Hospital, the biochemical status of 95% of patients will be appropriately categorized as euthyroidism, hypothyroidism or hyperthyroidism with only 5% discrepant (ie, normal TSH with abnormal FT4) results. In contrast, using FT4 alone as a first-line test correctly classifies only 84% of TFTs. Euthyroid status is observed in 50% of patients and FT4 assays on these samples will be excluded appropriately if a TSH-only protocol is adopted. Furthermore, we will save a quarter of the yearly cost of TFTs on reagents alone by performing TSH only. We conclude that TSH alone is an adequate first-line thyroid function test in Papua New Guinea and when it is normal no further FT4 test is necessary unless clinically indicated.