Dichotic listening studies of hemispheric asymmetry in brain damaged patients

In the present paper we review the empirical evidence for structural versus attentional explanations of the right ear advantage (REA) phenomenon in dichotic listening (DL). The ear advantage in DL is a behavioral "marker" of language function in the cerebral hemispheres. Dichotic listening data from four brain-lesioned patients are presented. The patients had a tumor or cyst in the left Sylvian region (2 cases); hemorrhage in the left frontotemporal region (1 case); and severe destruction of the left hemisphere (1 case). The results from all four patients showed marked reductions in correct recall of the right ear items, while left ear recall was left unaffected. In two of the cases, the DL data showed an immediate reinstatement of the REA after neurosurgery. It is concluded that the results favor a structural/anatomical explanation of the ear advantage phenomenon in DL, rather than an attentional bias explanation.