Related Experiment Video
Updated: Jul 14, 2026

Covalent Binding of Antibodies to Cellulose Paper Discs and Their Applications in Naked-eye Colorimetric Immunoassays
Published on: October 21, 2016
Usefulness of consensus conferences: the case of albumin
I Durand-Zaleski1, F Bonnet, H Rochant
1Department of Public Health, Hôpital Henri Mondor, Creteil, France.
Insights
Consensus conferences can improve medical practice by guiding treatment decisions. A 1989 conference on hypovolaemia significantly reduced albumin use and costs by 40% at one hospital.
Area of Science:
- Medical Practice
- Health Services Research
Background:
- The effectiveness of consensus conferences in clinical practice has been debated.
- Assessing the impact of consensus conferences on prescribing behavior is crucial for evidence-based medicine.
Purpose of the Study:
- To evaluate the influence of a 1989 consensus conference on the treatment of hypovolaemia on albumin prescribing practices.
- To determine the impact on albumin utilization and associated costs within a hospital setting.
Main Methods:
- Utilized blood bank data to track albumin use and costs across departments from 1987 to 1991.
- Disseminated conference recommendations through medical journals, direct mail, and meetings.
- Focused on a specific consensus conference addressing hypovolaemia treatment guidelines.
Main Results:
- Albumin use and costs decreased by 40% in the year following the conference and in subsequent years.
- This reduction occurred despite rising overall medical expenditure and stable patient admission numbers.
- Specific indications for albumin use were clarified, recommending alternatives for septic shock and vasoplegia-induced hypovolaemia.
Conclusions:
- Consensus conferences can be effective tools for improving medical practice and optimizing resource allocation.
- Key factors contributing to the success of this conference included a limited prescriber base, a homogeneous clinical setting, and consistent reinforcement of recommendations.
Abstract:
The usefulness of consensus conferences has been questioned. We have assessed the impact of a 1989 consensus conference about the treatment of hypovolaemia on prescribing practice at our hospital. Data available from the blood bank enabled us to follow albumin use and costs by department between 1987 and 1991. Medical journals, direct mail, and meetings were used to disseminate the recommendations of the consensus conference, which were that the only indications for albumin are massive haemorrhage, plasmapheresis, massive hypoalbuminaemia, and volume expansion in pregnancy; for hypovolaemia caused by septic shock or vasoplegia, fluid gelatins and crystalloids should be used. In the year after the conference, and in subsequent years, albumin use and costs were 40% lower than before the conference, even though total medical expenditure continued to rise and numbers of patients admitted did not change. We believe that consensus conferences can be a useful means of improving medical practice. The features that ensured success in this programme were the small number of prescribers, the homogeneous setting, and the frequent restatement of the recommendations.
Related Concept Videos
Case Studies
Confirmation Biases
Cognitive Dissonance
Social Proof
Groupthink
Ethical Issues
Ethical Concerns in Healthcare:

