The MD thesis in the training of a consultant physician

A postal survey was carried out among the 94 consultant physicians of the South Western region (83% response rate) to ascertain their attitudes to the tradition of obtaining an MD by thesis as part of a physician's training. Most felt that the practice was questionable, and only half felt that it made an important contribution. For some, doing an MD had been a painful experience, even a waste of time. Having an MD impressed selection committees, but did not appear to alter the length of training nor the probability of obtaining a consultant post in a teaching hospital. We suggest that the MD is of limited value in judging a junior doctor's suitability to be a consultant physician.