CT-guided lung biopsy: factors influencing diagnostic yield and complication rate

To determine factors influencing diagnostic yield in computed tomography (CT)-guided biopsy of lung lesions.

One hundred and ninety-five consecutive CT-guided lung biopsies were performed in 182 patients between August 1995 and September 2000 and either fine-needle aspirate samples for cytology or core biopsy samples for histology were collected. Procedures were divided into a diagnostic group (true-positive and true-negative results) and a non-diagnostic group (false-positive and false-negative results) and the factors affecting diagnostic accuracy assessed.

One hundred and fifty-six lesions (86%) were malignant, and 26 (14%) were benign. More than one biopsy was performed for 12 lesions. One hundred and thirty-two biopsies were true-positive, 27 true-negative and 36 false-negative. No false-positive results occurred in the study. Overall diagnostic accuracy was 81.5%. Significantly more core biopsies than fine-needle aspirates were diagnostic: 93 versus 78% (p<0.005). No difference was found in frequency of pneumothorax between these two groups. There was a difference in the average depth from the pleural surface of lesions in the diagnostic and non-diagnostic groups, but this did not attain statistical significance: 9.8 versus 17.2 mm (p=0.054).

In this study CT-guided lung biopsy core biopsy was a more accurate method of tissue sampling than fine-needle aspiration, and was not associated with an excess of complications.