Evaluation of two protocols of uremic rat model: partial nephrectomy and infarction

Animal models of chronic renal failure have been mostly achieved by partial ablation of renal parenchyma, the two most common techniques employed being surgical resection or infarction. Evaluation of the uremic model using these two techniques was carried out in Wistar rats. Two weeks after operative procedure, measured serum urea levels in the resection and infarction models were 59.1 and 64.3 mg/dL (normal range 15.6-24.4 mg/dL) respectively. However, the standard deviation in the former was significantly lower, 6.3 vs. 97.1 mg/dL from infarction model, p = 0.007. A consistent degree of glomerular filtration rate reduction was obtained in the resection model, resulting in 20-30% of normal creatinine clearance. This compared favorably with the creatinine clearance range (0.3-74% of normal) from the infarction model, in which two animals died of uremia and seven had higher than 50% of normal creatinine clearance. It is reasonable to attribute reproducibility and homogeneity demonstrated in the resection model to (i) more precise control of renal ablation extent with surgical techniques and (ii) less interplay of confounding injury mechanism to remnant kidney. These data support superiority of the resection model as an experimental tool for pathophysiological and/or interventional investigations of chronic renal failure.