MHC class I+ and class I- HPV16-associated tumours expressing the E7 oncoprotein do not cross-react in immunization/challenge experiments

It has been demonstrated repeatedly that a high proportion of tumours derived from MHC class I+ precursors are MHC class I-. Since a major task in immunotherapy strategies for treatment of malignancies is to develop polyvalent tumour vaccines efficient against a broad spectrum of tumours, we have examined whether MHC class I+ cell-based tumour vaccines can cross-protect against homologous MHC class I- tumour challenge and vice versa. For these purposes, we have used two oncogenic cell lines induced independently by co-transfection of murine H-2b cells with E61E7 HPV16 and activated Ha-ras oncogenes, the tumours TC-1 (MHC class I+, HPV16 E7+) and E7+). Surprisingly, it was found that these two tumours do not cross-react, although both of them contain the crucial HPV16-coded tumour rejection antigen E7. Preimmunization with the MHC class I+ tumour did not protect against a subsequent challenge with the MHC class I- tumour and vice versa; however, immunization with the TC-1 tumour could protect syngeneic mice against the TC-1 tumour challenge and, similarly, immunization with the MK16/1/IIIABC tumour could protect mice against the MK16/1/IIIABC tumour challenge. If this finding can also be confirmed as a more general phenomenon with other MHC class I+ and class 1- tumours, it could have serious implications for design of immunotherapeutic vaccines and protocols.