Secondary caries detection by DIAGNOdent and radiography: a comparative in vitro study

DIAGNOdent is now well documented for detection of primary occlusal caries, but not as yet for secondary caries. The aim of this study was to investigate the application of DIAGNOdent for in vitro detection of secondary caries. The material comprised 66 extracted teeth: 48 with amalgam restorations and 18 with tooth-colored restorations. Digital images of occlusal surfaces were captured for each specimen. The teeth were mounted in groups of 3 or 4 in plaster blocks simulating their anatomical positions. Bitewing radiographs of each block were assessed for secondary caries by 5 observers. The margins of each restoration were carefully scanned with DIAGNOdent; the site of the highest reading was localized in digital images; and the corresponding values were registered. Marginal integrity and staining were also documented. The restorations were then removed and the teeth were hemi-sectioned. For verification, two observers working together examined all the cavities under a stereomicroscope at 16 x magnification followed by probing. Sensitivity and specificity for DIAGNOdent and conventional radiography were 0.77/0.81 and 0.65/0.81, respectively. Regarding ROC analyses, the Az values were 0.89 and 0.72 for DIAGNOdent and radiography. For DIAGNOdent, the false-positive fraction included only stained teeth. Cohen's kappa statistics disclosed moderate agreement between the 2 methods, with an agreement of 56%. DIAGNOdent tended to give more positive diagnoses than bitewing radiography. The results indicate that DIAGNOdent may be a helpful tool for detecting secondary caries.