Outsourcing of primary care: satisfaction level in the Israeli Defense Forces

To examine the effect of outsourcing primary care services on satisfaction levels among career soldiers in the Israeli Defense Forces (IDF).

Data were acquired via self-administered satisfaction questionnaires during the visits of soldiers and civilians to primary care clinics in military bases, hospitals, and HMO settings. Multivariable analyses (GLM) used the SAS statistical program.

Two hundred thirty civilians and 618 soldiers (200 in hospital clinics, 277 in military clinics, and 141 in HMO clinics) completed 848 questionnaires. Gender did not influence satisfaction level (alpha < 0.05). Age and rank influenced two parameters: surroundings (p = 0.0277) and availability of the medical service (p = 0.0368). Location (hospital clinic, HMO clinic, and military clinic) was the primary variable influencing and predicting satisfaction level (11.6%). "Quality of medical care" predicts only 4% of satisfaction level. Soldiers in HMO settings expressed a higher degree of satisfaction particularly in availability of service, quality of service, general satisfaction, and courtesy.

Career soldiers in Israel value all aspects of primary care given by a civilian HMO and are willing to accept a change (outsourcing primary care to a civilian provider). As a result, decision makers should expand the provision of these services to all career soldiers in Israel. Outsourcing of medical services can serve as a model to military corps worldwide.