Bethanechol provocation testing does not predict symptom relief after cholecystectomy for acalculous biliary pain

The currently accepted hypothesis to explain acalculous gallbladder pain is the lack of contractile co-ordination between the body and neck. We have previously shown that bethanechol, a muscarinic stimulant causes differential stimulation of these two regions.

To evaluate the reliability of bethanechol-induced gallbladder contraction in predicting symptom relief after cholecystectomy in patients with acalculous gallbladder disease.

Fifty-one patients underwent a bethanechol provocation test together with serial ultrasound to determine gallbladder emptying. McGill pain questionnaires were completed, and patients positive for pain (bethanechol provocation test +ve) were offered cholecystectomy, and patients negative for pain (bethanechol provocation test -ve) were reassessed at 6 months and offered cholecystectomy if symptoms persisted. All patients answered pain questionnaires either 6 months after surgery or as follow-up.

There was no difference in the percentage of gallbladder emptying between the bethanechol provocation test +ve and bethanechol provocation test -ve groups. Fifty-three percent of bethanechol provocation test +ve patients and 54% of bethanechol provocation test -ve patients still remained symptomatic 6 months after surgery. Conclusion. Gallbladder pain provoked by bethanechol does not predict symptom relief after cholecystectomy.