Comparative study of different iron compounds in inhibition of sphaerotilus growth

The effectiveness of iron compounds on growth inhibition of Sphaerotilus species was compared. In this study, two strains of Sphaerotilus were tested with different iron concentrations in a synthetic sewage (S-medium) as formulated by Lackey and Wattie (Sewage Works J. 12:669-684, 1940). For both strains, >80% inhibition of the maximum respiration rate was obtained by the following levels of soluble iron concentrations at pH 6.0: iron citrate, 20 mg/liter as Fe; iron cysteine, 5 mg/liter as Fe; and ferrous sulfate, 10 mg/liter as Fe. At a pH of 6.7 with iron citrate (20 mg/liter as Fe), inhibition of both strains was in excess of 50%. Insoluble iron compounds, such as iron hydroxides and ferrous carbonate, were found to be much less effective than the soluble iron compounds as inhibitors of these two strains. Aged iron hydroxide (500 mg/liter as Fe) produced a 70% inhibition in the maximum respiration rate while fresh iron hydroxide (52 mg/liter as Fe) and ferrous carbonate (500 mg/liter as Fe) produced a 20% inhibition. Chemical analyses of the iron-inhibited Sphaerotilus strains showed a close relationship between the inhibition of the organism's growth and the amount of iron sorbed by the organism.