Related Experiment Video
Updated: Aug 13, 2026

Using Visual and Narrative Methods to Achieve Fair Process in Clinical Care
Published on: February 16, 2011
In search of the true self: a clinical journey through the vale of soul-making
1Pennine Care NHS Trust, Standard Care Community Mental Health Team, Rochdale, UK. peter.wilkin@nhs.net
Once a person accepts any form of mainstream mental health care, she is faced with the paradox of disabling caring. Every time an emotionally distressed individual is professionally rescued, she forfeits a golden opportunity to discover and utilize her own healing potential. Yet within a mental health service that is heavily medicalized and investing more and more in time-limited therapies, can it ever be otherwise? Drawing on the developmental theory of Donald Winnicott, together with the poet John Keats' concept of 'Soul-making', this case study provides an account of therapy delivered from outside the parameters of a health-illness model of caring. It acknowledges human suffering as a natural and inevitable part of life and, whilst acknowledging the value of therapeutic companionship, proclaims the mentally distressed person as best placed to navigate her own recovery.
Once a person accepts any form of mainstream mental health care, she is faced with the paradox of disabling caring. Every time an emotionally distressed individual is professionally rescued, she forfeits a golden opportunity to discover and utilize her own healing potential. Yet within a mental health service that is heavily medicalized and investing more and more in time-limited therapies, can it ever be otherwise? Drawing on the developmental theory of Donald Winnicott, together with the poet John Keats' concept of 'Soul-making', this case study provides an account of therapy delivered from outside the parameters of a health-illness model of caring. It acknowledges human suffering as a natural and inevitable part of life and, whilst acknowledging the value of therapeutic companionship, proclaims the mentally distressed person as best placed to navigate her own recovery.
Related Concept Videos
Understanding the Self
Introspection
The Looking Glass Self
Structure of Self
Components of the Mind: Id, Ego, and Superego
The Sense of Self: Reflected Self-Appraisal and Social Comparison
Altered States of Awareness
The ingestion of substances like stimulants or hallucinogens leads to chemical alterations in the brain that...