How inaccuracies in protein structure models affect estimates of protein-ligand interactions: computational analysis of HIV-I protease inhibitor binding

The influence of possible inaccuracies that can arise during homology modeling of protein structures used for ligand binding studies were investigated with the molecular mechanics generalized Born surface area (MM-GBSA) method. For this, a family of well-characterized HIV-I protease-inhibitor complexes was used. Validation of MM-GBSA led to a correlation coefficient ranging from 0.72 to 0.93 between calculated and experimental binding free energies DeltaG. All calculated DeltaG values were based on molecular dynamics simulations with explicit solvent. Errors introduced into the protein structure through misplacement of side-chains during rotamer modeling led to a correlation coefficient between DeltaG(calc) and DeltaG(exp) of 0.75 compared with 0.90 for the correctly placed side chains. This is in contrast to homology models for members of the retroviral protease family with template structures ranging in sequence identity between 32% and 51%. For these protein models, the correlation coefficients vary between 0.84 and 0.87, which is considerably closer to the original protein (0.90). It is concluded that HIV-I low sequence identity with the template structure still allows creating sufficiently reliable homology models to be used for ligand-binding studies, although placement of the rotamers is a critical step during the modeling.