Laparoscopic cholecystectomy with a three-trocar 5-mm instrument approach

The natural evolution of laparoscopy seems to be the use of miniature instruments and, where possible, a reduction of the number of trocars used. We report the results of our experience with all 5-mm instrument three-trocar cholecystectomy vs. the conventional laparoscopy approach. From July 2002 to July 2005 a total of 518 patients underwent laparoscopic cholecystectomy: 268 of them (51.7%) were operated on with a 5-mm three-trocar approach. The primary end point was the feasibility rate of the technique. Secondary end points were safety and the impact of the technique on the duration of laparoscopy. There were two conversions to laparotomy--one in each group--while a conversion to the classical approach for the three-trocar group was registered in 9.3% of the cases. Occurrence of minor complications was 3.6% (9 cases) with the conventional approach as against 3.7% (10 cases) with the three-trocar approach. The present experience shows that 5-mm three-trocar cholecystectomy is a safe, easy, effective and reproducible approach for gallbladder disease. Such features make the technique a challenging alternative to conventional laparoscopy in the treatment of cholecystopathy, in both the acute and elective setting.