Related Experiment Video
Updated: Jul 6, 2026

Basophil Activation Test for Allergy Diagnosis
Published on: May 31, 2021
Relevance of positive patch-test reactions to fragrance mix
Steven A Devos1, Lieve Constandt, Ron A Tupker
1Department of Dermatology, Hospital H. Serruys, Ostend, Belgium.
Background:
Fragrances are an important cause of allergic contact dermatitis. We presume that the traditional fragrance mix (FM) detects 70 to 80% of fragrance-allergic patients. FM has an irritant potential. Weak positive reactions may have a greater chance of being irrelevant than strong reactions.
Objective:
To improve the appraisal of FM patch-test reactions, we studied the relevance of reactions of different strength. We also studied the predictive value of the following on the relevance of the initial FM patch-test results: patch-test results of a repeated FM test; results of patch tests with balsam of Peru, colophony, and ingredients of the mix; and (history of) atopic dermatitis.
Methods:
One hundred thirty-eight patients who had doubtful positive (?+) or positive (+ to +++) reactions were included in the study. We determined relevance by history taking, location and course of the dermatitis, and additional patch testing. Patients were retested with FM and with each ingredient separately.
Results:
The relevance of reactions to FM increases with the strength of the reactions. Predictors of relevance are the results of retesting with FM, the results of tests with the ingredients, and a history and/or present symptoms of atopic dermatitis.
Conclusion:
Retesting with FM and its ingredients may add to the benefit of patch testing.
Insights
Fragrance mix (FM) patch testing can identify fragrance allergies. Stronger reactions and atopic dermatitis history predict relevance, improving diagnosis accuracy.
Area of Science:
- Dermatology
- Allergology
- Contact Dermatitis
Background:
- Fragrances are a common trigger for allergic contact dermatitis.
- The traditional fragrance mix (FM) identifies 70-80% of fragrance-allergic individuals.
- FM patch tests have irritant potential, complicating interpretation of weak reactions.
Purpose of the Study:
- To enhance the interpretation of FM patch test reactions.
- To assess the relevance of different reaction strengths.
- To evaluate predictors for the relevance of initial FM patch test results.
Main Methods:
- 138 patients with doubtful or positive FM reactions were studied.
- Relevance was determined by history, dermatitis presentation, and further patch testing.
- Patients underwent repeat FM testing and individual ingredient testing.
Main Results:
- Reaction relevance to FM increases with reaction strength.
- Predictors of relevance include repeat FM testing, ingredient testing, and atopic dermatitis history.
- Atopic dermatitis history and/or symptoms are significant predictors.
Conclusions:
- Retesting with FM and its components improves diagnostic benefit.
- Assessing reaction strength and patient history refines allergy diagnosis.
- Further testing aids in determining the clinical significance of fragrance allergies.
Related Concept Videos
Drug Toxicity: Allergic Reactions
Allergic Reactions
Allergic Drug Reactions
Allergic Reactions: Anaphylaxis
Cross-reactivity
Hypersensitivity Reactions: Delayed Hypersensitivity Reactions

