Related Experiment Video
Updated: Jul 5, 2026

Microbiological Rapid On-Site Evaluation for Pulmonary Infectious Diseases
Published on: March 1, 2024
Is there a Rosenberg school?
1Department of History, Stony Brook University, Stony Brook, New York 11794-4348, USA. nancy.tomes@sunysb.edu
Insights
This study examines whether Charles Rosenberg
Area of Science:
- Medical History
- Historiography
- Social History of Medicine
Background:
- Charles Rosenberg's significant influence on the history of medicine, beginning with "The Cholera Years" (1962).
- His impact extends beyond publications to his roles as a graduate teacher, advisor, and mentor.
- This article investigates the existence of a distinct "Rosenberg School" in medical historiography.
Discussion:
- The authors, former students of Rosenberg, analyze his scholarly legacy and pedagogical influence.
- They compare Rosenberg's work with that of his students across different generations.
- The discussion addresses the challenges of applying Rosenberg's conceptual framework, developed for pre-1920 medicine, to late 20th-century American medical history.
Key Insights:
- There is no "Rosenberg School" in the traditional sense of a rigidly defined academic movement.
- However, common assumptions, termed "Rosenberg Rules," have been transmitted from Rosenberg to his influenced scholars.
- These "rules" represent shared intellectual tendencies and approaches to the history of medicine.
Outlook:
- Future research could explore the evolution and adaptation of Rosenberg's ideas in contemporary medical history.
- Investigating the "Rosenberg Rules" further may reveal enduring themes in the historiography of American medicine.
- The study highlights the dynamic nature of scholarly influence and the development of academic traditions.
Abstract:
Since his first book The Cholera Years appeared in 1962, Charles Rosenberg has had an enormous influence on the history of medicine. Not the least of that influence has been exercised through his role as a graduate teacher, advisor, and mentor. This article compares Rosenberg's work with that of his students, to see if there is such a historiographic identity as the "Rosenberg School." The authors, two Rosenberg students from different generations, conclude that there is not such a school, at least in the classic sense of the term. Yet they argue that certain common assumptions, or "Rosenberg Rules," have been passed on from Rosenberg to the other scholars he has influenced. They also discuss the challenges they have encountered in applying Charles's conceptual framework, worked out primarily in pre-1920 terms, to the late twentieth-century history of American medicine.
Related Concept Videos
Robbers Cave
The Sense of Self: Reflected Self-Appraisal and Social Comparison
The Stanford Prison Experiment
Bullying
Social Foundations of Self II: The Generalized Other
Response Surface Methodology
The process of RSM involves several key steps:

