Related Experiment Videos
Sticks and stones may break my bones ... reasoning about illness causality and body functioning in children who have
E C Perrin1, A G Sayer, J B Willett
1Department of Pediatrics, University of Massachusetts Medical Center, Worcester.
Insights
Children with chronic illnesses like seizure disorders or orthopedic conditions show different understandings of illness compared to healthy peers. Their cognitive development and illness concepts are influenced by age and specific health conditions.
Area of Science:
- Developmental Psychology
- Pediatric Health
- Cognitive Science
Background:
- Children's understanding of illness and bodily functions evolves with age.
- Limited research exists on how chronic illnesses impact these concepts in children compared to healthy peers.
Purpose of the Study:
- To investigate differences in illness causality and bodily functioning concepts between healthy children and those with chronic conditions.
- To explore the influence of age and specific illnesses on children's cognitive reasoning and conceptual understanding.
Main Methods:
- A comparative study involving 49 children with seizure disorders, 47 with orthopedic conditions, and 96 healthy children.
- Participants ranged from 5 to 16 years old, all with normal intelligence.
- Assessed general reasoning skills and understanding of illness causality and bodily functioning.
Main Results:
- Children with orthopedic conditions showed less sophisticated reasoning and illness concepts than healthy children.
- Children with seizure disorders had similar reasoning but less sophisticated illness concepts compared to healthy peers.
- Concepts of body functioning did not differ by illness status, and were more sophisticated in chronically ill children when cognitive reasoning was controlled.
Conclusions:
- Chronic illness, particularly orthopedic conditions and seizure disorders, impacts children's conceptual development regarding illness.
- Specific illness characteristics may influence cognitive development in children.
- Further research is needed to understand the nuanced effects of different chronic illnesses on children's understanding of health and disease.
Abstract:
Children's concepts about illness causality and bodily functioning change in a predictable way with advancing age. Differences in the understanding of these concepts in healthy children vs children with a chronic illness have not been clearly delineated. This study included 49 children with a seizure disorder, 47 children with an orthopaedic condition, and 96 healthy children, all with normal intelligence and ranging in age from 5 to 16 years. It demonstrates systematic differences in children's general reasoning skills and in their understanding of concepts about illness causality and bodily functioning, as a function of their age and experience of illness. At all ages, children who had a condition with orthopaedic involvement reported less sophisticated general reasoning and concepts about illness than did healthy children; children with a seizure disorder reported similar general reasoning skills to those of healthy children, but considerably less sophisticated concepts about illness. Children's concepts about body functioning did not differ as a function of the presence of a chronic illness. When their different levels of general cognitive reasoning were statistically controlled, children with a chronic illness had somewhat more sophisticated concepts about bodily functioning than did healthy children. Differences in conceptual development among children with different types of illnesses lead to interesting speculations with regard to the effects of particular illness characteristics on children's cognitive development.