Related Experiment Videos
Interscorer reliability for the Hand Test administered to children.
1Department of Educational Foundations, State University College, Buffalo, New York 14222.
Perceptual and Motor Skills
|June 1, 1991
Summary
The Hand Test shows potential for assessing children's personalities, with good reliability for quantitative scores. Modifications may improve qualitative score reliability for young children.
Area of Science:
- Psychological assessment
- Child psychology
- Personality testing
Background:
- The Hand Test is a projective measure used to assess personality.
- Its utility in assessing children's personalities requires further validation.
- Interscorer reliability is crucial for the consistent application of psychological tests.
Purpose of the Study:
- To assess the utility of the Hand Test as a quick and reliable personality measure for 100 children.
- To estimate the interscorer reliability of the Hand Test using intraclass correlations and Kappa coefficients.
- To identify potential areas for improving the Hand Test's reliability in child assessments.
Main Methods:
- The Hand Test was administered to 100 children.
- Interscorer reliability was calculated using intraclass correlations and Kappa coefficients.
- Scorers underwent training prior to data collection.
Main Results:
- Satisfactory intraclass correlations were achieved for quantitative scores (20/22 > .70) and qualitative scores (12/27 > .70) after training.
- Kappa coefficients were generally lower than intraclass correlations.
- Lower reliability for qualitative scores may be linked to scorer memory overload and low response frequency.
Conclusions:
- The Hand Test demonstrates acceptable reliability for quantitative scores in children, comparable to other projective tests.
- Modifications to administration directions for young children and clearer scoring rules are recommended.
- Further research is needed to enhance the reliability of qualitative scores for child personality assessment.