Related Experiment Video
Updated: Jun 22, 2026

Ole Isacson: Development of New Therapies for Parkinson's Disease
Published on: April 29, 2007
Yearning for certainty and the critique of medicine as "science"
1Department of Philosophy, Loyola University Chicago, 6525 N. Sheridan Road, Chicago, IL 60626, USA. mwaymac@luc.edu
Abstract:
A debate has simmered concerning the nature of clinical reasoning, especially diagnostic reasoning: is it a "science" or an "art"? The trend since the seventeenth century has been to regard medical reasoning as scientific reasoning, and the most advanced clinical reasoning is the most scientific. However, in recent years, several scholars have argued that clinical reasoning is clearly not "science" reasoning, but is in fact a species of narratival or hermeneutical reasoning. The study reviews this dispute, and argues that in a theoretical sense, the dispute rests upon a naïve--but very popular--caricature of what constitutes "science reasoning." But, if the dispute rests upon just such a caricature, why is it so persistent? The study concludes by suggesting that we, as patients and as physicians, have deep psychological tendencies that incline us to adopt the very naïve "science" concept/model of diagnostic reasoning, even if (or when) we understand its inaptness.
Related Concept Videos
The Scientific Method in Nursing Process
When using research findings to change practice, one must understand the process used to guide a study. The scientific method is a systematic, step-by-step process that supports the data's validity, reliability, and generalizability. As a result, findings can be safely...
Obedience
Patient-centered Care
The Scientific Method
The Scientific Method
The Scientific Method
