Analysis of ureteric stent kinking forces: the role of curvature in stent failure

Matthew S Christman1, James O L'Esperance, Chong H Choe

  • 1Department of Urology, Naval Medical Center San Diego, San Diego, CA, USA.

BJU International
|August 29, 2009
PubMed
Abstract

Insights

Silhouette ureteric stents demonstrate superior resistance to kinking and curvature, potentially reducing failures in malignant ureteral obstructions. Smaller stents generally allow more bending before failure.

Area of Science:

  • Urology
  • Biomedical Engineering
  • Medical Device Design

Background:

  • Ureteral stent failure is common, with malignant obstruction causing approximately 50% of failures.
  • Kinking and excessive curvature are primary modes of ureteric stent failure.

Purpose of the Study:

  • To quantify the kinking forces and degree of curvature leading to failure in various ureteral stents.
  • To identify stent designs with improved resistance to mechanical failure.

Main Methods:

  • Mechanical testing of multiple ureteral stent models (Silhouette, Sof-Curl Tecoflex, Polaris Ultra, Percuflex) with varying French sizes.
  • Measurement of the force required to induce stent kinking.
  • Calculation of the degree of curvature at the point of stent failure.

Main Results:

  • Silhouette 4.6 F and 6 F stents exhibited the highest resistance to kinking and curvature-induced failure.
  • Smaller diameter stents generally tolerated greater degrees of curvature before failure compared to larger stents.

Conclusions:

  • Silhouette ureteric stents offer enhanced resistance to kinking and greater allowable curvature.
  • These properties may lead to reduced stent failure rates in patients with malignant ureteral obstruction and other retroperitoneal conditions.

Related Concept Videos

Bending of Curved Members - Strain Analysis01:14

Bending of Curved Members - Strain Analysis

The mechanics of deformation in curved members, such as beams or arches, under bending moments, involve complex responses. When such a member, symmetric about the y-axis and shaped like a segment of a circle centered at point C, is subjected to equal and opposite forces, its curvature and surface lengths change significantly. This alteration results in the shift of the curvature's center from C to C', indicating a tighter curve.
The important part of bending analysis for such a member is the...
Residual Stresses in Bending01:18

Residual Stresses in Bending

In the study of elastoplastic members subjected to bending moments, understanding the loading and unloading phases is crucial for assessing material behavior and structural integrity. During the loading phase, as the bending moment increases, the material initially responds elastically, adhering to Hooke's Law, where stress is directly proportional to strain. When the load exceeds the yield strength, plastic deformation occurs, resulting in permanent strain and deformation that remains even...
Stresses under Combined Loadings01:23

Stresses under Combined Loadings

When analyzing a bent tube with a circular cross-section subjected to multiple forces, it is crucial to determine the stress distribution in order to maintain structural integrity under varied load conditions.
The process begins by slicing the tube at critical points and analyzing the internal forces and stress components at these sections, focusing on the centroid. Normal stresses, generated by axial forces and bending moments, are either compressive or tensile and vary across the section from...
Stress-Strain Diagram - Ductile Materials01:24

Stress-Strain Diagram - Ductile Materials

The stress-strain relationship in ductile materials such as structural steel or aluminium is intricate and progresses through several stages. When a specimen is loaded, it initially exhibits a linear length increase, depicted by a steep straight line on the stress-strain diagram. It indicates the material is elastically deforming and will return to its original shape once unloaded. However, when a critical stress value is reached, plastic deformation begins. This stage sees substantial...
Deformations in a Symmetric Member in Bending01:18

Deformations in a Symmetric Member in Bending

When analyzing the deformation of a symmetric prismatic member subjected to bending by equal and opposite couples, it becomes clear that as the member bends, the originally straight lines on its wider faces curve into circular arcs, with a constant radius centered at a point known as Point C. This phenomenon helps to understand the stress and strain distribution within the member more clearly.
When the member is segmented into tiny cubic elements, it is observed that the primary stress...
Plastic Deformations01:14

Plastic Deformations

It is essential to understand how structural members behave under plastic deformation when the bending stress exceeds the material's yield strength. This state of deformation permanently alters the shape of the member, in contrast to the linear elastic behavior observed before yielding. The strain at any point in the member is expressed in terms of maximum strain. Notably, the neutral axis, which coincides with the centroid during elastic bending, shifts away from the centroid under plastic...