In search for an optimal methodology to calculate the valence electron affinities of temporary anions

Recently, we have proposed an approach for finding the valence anion ground state, based on the stabilization exerted by a polar solvent; the methodology used standard DFT methods and relatively inexpensive basis sets and yielded correct electron affinity (EA) values by gradually decreasing the dielectric constant of the medium. In order to address the overall performance of the new methodology, to find the best conditions for stabilizing the valence state and to evaluate its scope and limitations, we gathered a pool of 60 molecules, 25 of them bearing the conventional valence state as the ground anion and 35 for which the lowest anion state found holds the extra electron in a diffuse orbital around the molecule (non valence state). The results obtained by testing this representative set suggest a very good performance for most species having an experimental EA less negative than -3.0 eV; the correlation at the B3LYP/6-311+G(2df,p) level being y = 1.01x + 0.06, with a correlation index of 0.985. As an alternative, the time dependent DFT (TD-DFT) approach was also tested with both B3LYP and PBE0 functionals. The methodology we proposed shows a comparable or better accuracy with respect to TD-DFT, although the TD-DFT approach with the PBE0 functional is suggested as a suitable estimate for species with the most negative EAs (ca.-2.5 to -3.5 eV), for which stabilization strategies can hardly reach the valence state. As an application, a pool of 8 compounds of key biological interest with EAs which remain unknown or unclear were predicted using the new methodology.