Rural medicine and the closed society. Pregnancy outcomes among Amish and non-Amish women

A rural family practitioner may be responsible for the general medical and obstetric needs of a closed population such as the Old Order Amish. Until recently, the Amish in southern New York State have preferred to receive obstetric care in the home from traditional Amish midwives. Acceptance of prenatal care and hospital deliveries by rural physicians appears to be increasingly frequent among Amish primiparas in southern New York State, while non-Amish in the area have been seeking these services for decades regardless of parity. This retrospective chart review examines first pregnancy outcomes of Amish (N = 39) and non-Amish (N = 145) women who delivered their babies at a rural hospital in southern New York State during a four-year period. Little difference was found between the two groups of women regarding the overall good health of their first babies. In the Amish population there was less variability in maternal age, season in which the birth occurred, labor duration, and birth weight of babies. The Amish had their first child an average of one year later than the non-Amish. While research on a larger sample will be necessary to fully explore Amish vs non-Amish variances, this study demonstrates the effect that traditions and customs of a closed society such as the Amish may have on obstetric practice.