Three-dimensional photon treatment planning in carcinoma of the larynx

The role of three-dimensional (3-D) treatment planning in the definitive treatment of carcinoma of the larynx with radiation was evaluated at four institutions as part of an NCI contract. A total of 30 different treatment approaches were devised for two patients with larynx cancer. CT scans were obtained for both patients and various treatment planning tools were employed to optimize beam arrangements and to evaluate the resulting dose distribution. The effect on dose distribution of a number of factors was also examined: 1) the use of dose calculation algorithms which correct for tissue inhomogeneities, 2) the variation of the CT numbers used for inhomogeneity corrections to simulate inaccuracies in the knowledge of the CT numbers, and 3) the modification of beam energy. A multitude of data was used in plan evaluation and a numerical score was given to each plan to estimate the tumor control probability and the normal tissue complication probability. We found 3-D treatment planning to be of potential value in optimizing treatment plans in larynx cancer. Improved target coverage was achieved when complete information describing 3-D geometry of the anatomy was utilized. In some cases, the treatment planning tools employed, such as the beam's eye view, helped devise novel beam arrangements which were useful alternatives to standard techniques. We found little effect of change in CT number on dose distributions. A comparison between dose distributions calculated with tissue inhomogeneity corrections to those calculated without this correction showed little difference. We did find some improvement in the dose to the primary tumor volume at lower beam energies, but with an increased larynx volume potentially receiving doses above tolerance.