Evaluating elastic network models of crystalline biological molecules with temperature factors, correlated motions,...

In this study, the variance-covariance matrix of protein motions is used to compare several elastic network models within the theoretical framework of x-ray scattering from crystals. A set of 33 ultra-high resolution structures is used to characterize the average scaling behavior of the vibrational density of states and make comparisons between experimental and theoretical temperature factors. Detailed investigations of the vibrational density of states, correlations, and predicted diffuse x-ray scatter are carried out for crystalline Staphylococcal nuclease; correlations and diffuse x-ray scatter are also compared to predictions from the translation, libration, screw model and a liquid-like dynamics model. We show that elastic network models developed to best predict temperature factors without regard for the crystal environment have relatively strong long-range interactions that yield very short-ranged atom-atom correlations. Further, we find that the low-frequency modes dominate the variance-covariance matrix only for those models with a physically reasonable vibrational density of states, and the fraction of modes required to converge the correlations is higher than that typically used for elastic network model studies. The practical implications are explored using computed diffuse x-ray scatter, which can be measured experimentally.