Stickleback fishes: Bridging the gap between population biology and paleobiology

Integration of evolutionary mechanisms and phylogeny requires study of phenotypes that change in the fossil record and continue to evolve in extant populations. Pelvic reduction in the three-spined stickle-back has evolved rapidly in a Miocene fossil assemblage and in numerous extant isolated lake populations throughout its distribution. Although pelvic reduction is caused by selection, expression of reduced pelvic phenotypes is constrained by development and other factors. However, lineages with pelvis reduction rapidly go extinct while lineages that retain the fully formed pelvic girdle tend to persist. Existence of pelvic reduction since the Miocene has depended on an equilibrium between divergence and extinction. The phylogenetic topology resulting from this process differs greatly from the conventional view of evolutionary history, and could only be recognized by analysis of both extant populations and fossil material. If this phylogenetic topology is common, it may help to account for the different perceptions that population biologists and paleobiologists have of evolutionary tempo.