Volume changes of grafted autogenous bone in sinus augmentation procedure
Carolina Sbordone1, Ludovico Sbordone, Paolo Toti
1Department of Maxillo-Facial Surgery, School of Medicine, University of Naples Federico II, Naples, Italy. lsbordon@med.unipi.it
This study examined how bone grafts used in sinus augmentation procedures change over time. Researchers analyzed computed tomography scans of patients who had implants placed after bone grafting. They found that block grafts from the chin had the least resorption, while particulate grafts from the iliac crest had slightly more. The study also showed that graft thickness, contact area with the bone, and the volume of the recipient site influenced remodeling. Grafts molded to less than 4 mm thickness and with minimal surface area in the sinus cavity had better outcomes. These findings may help surgeons choose graft types and shapes that lead to more predictable results in dental implant procedures.
Area of Science:
- Oral and maxillofacial surgery
- Dental implantology
- Bone grafting techniques
Background:
Sinus augmentation procedures rely on predictable bone remodeling to support dental implants. Prior research has shown that autogenous bone grafts influence long-term outcomes, but the relationship between graft geometry and resorption remains unclear. Established knowledge includes the general use of iliac crest and chin bone as graft sources, though specific 3D remodeling patterns are less understood. This paper's contribution lies in analyzing how graft shape and recipient site characteristics affect bone resorption. No prior work had resolved the interplay between graft thickness, surface area, and sinus volume in predicting remodeling. This gap motivated the use of advanced imaging to track volumetric changes over time. The study introduces a novel approach by correlating 3D features with resorption rates. It also explores how graft positioning impacts long-term stability. These findings may refine surgical planning for better implant success.
Purpose Of The Study:
The study aimed to evaluate how osseous remodeling relates to the 3D features of grafted bone and the recipient site. It also sought to determine if graft density and source influence resorption rates. The specific problem addressed is the variability in bone resorption following sinus augmentation. Motivation came from the need to improve implant placement outcomes through better graft design. The study focused on comparing block and particulate grafts from different donor sites. It aimed to identify optimal graft configurations for minimal resorption. The researchers proposed that graft thickness and contact area with the basal bone affect remodeling. By analyzing these factors, the study could inform surgical techniques for more predictable results.
Main Methods:
The study used a retrospective chart review of patients who underwent sinus lifting and grafting procedures. Radiographic analysis was performed using computed tomography scans before and after implant positioning. The volumetric remodeling was measured as a percentage of residual bone (%R) at 1 year. The 3D features of the graft and recipient site were analyzed using methods described by Smolka et al. and Krennmair et al. Spearman correlation tests were applied to identify statistically significant relationships between %R and graft features. Two- and multidimensional scattergrams were used to visualize these correlations. The study included 25 grafts from either the iliac crest or chin. Data were analyzed to determine how graft shape and placement influenced resorption rates.
Main Results:
Computed tomography scans showed that block grafts from the chin had the lowest resorption rate (97.9% residual bone). Particulate grafts from the iliac crest had a 93.8% residual bone rate, while block grafts from the same site had 83.3%. Three- and four-dimensional scattergrams revealed that graft thickness, contact area with basal bone, and sinus cavity projection influenced remodeling. Grafts with a thickness of less than 4 mm and minimal surface area protruding into the sinus showed favorable outcomes. Block grafts with reduced contact surface (≤ 4 cm²) also displayed minimal resorption. The study found that graft volume and recipient site characteristics correlated strongly with %R. These findings suggest that specific 3D configurations can reduce resorption. The results highlight the importance of graft geometry in predicting remodeling patterns.
Conclusions:
The study's findings suggest that graft geometry and recipient site characteristics significantly influence bone resorption. Block grafts from the chin showed the least resorption, while particulate grafts from the iliac crest performed better than block grafts from the same site. The researchers propose that graft thickness and contact area with the basal bone are critical factors in predicting remodeling. The authors suggest that grafts molded to less than 4 mm thickness and with minimal sinus cavity projection may lead to favorable outcomes. These conclusions are based on the observed correlations between 3D features and resorption rates. The study does not generalize beyond the specific graft types and configurations tested. The authors emphasize the need for further research to validate these findings in larger cohorts. The implications are limited to the specific surgical context described in the paper.
Frequently Asked Questions
The study found that block grafts from the chin had the lowest resorption rate (97.9%), while particulate grafts from the iliac crest had a 93.8% residual bone rate.
The researchers used computed tomography scans to measure volumetric remodeling as a percentage of residual bone (%R) at 1 year after implant positioning.
The study suggests that grafts molded to less than 4 mm thickness may lead to favorable remodeling due to reduced resorption rates observed in such configurations.
The study found that grafts placed in recipient sites with a small basal bone volume (≤ 2.5 mL) showed better remodeling when the graft thickness was less than 4 mm.
Grafts with a reduced surface area protruding into the sinus (≤ 5 cm²) displayed minimal resorption, according to the study’s findings.
The authors propose that specific graft configurations may improve outcomes, but they emphasize the need for further research to validate these results in larger studies.

