Airway refractoriness to inhaled mannitol after repeated challenge

Exercise and inhaled mannitol are thought to cause bronchoconstriction through a similar mechanism in asthma. The response to exercise becomes refractory with repeated challenges. This study aimed to investigate whether repeated challenge with mannitol induces refractoriness, as with exercise. Forty-one children with asthma underwent two consecutive dose-response mannitol challenges (Phase 1); the second challenge proceeded after recovery (FEV(1) : 95% or more of baseline value) from the first. The response to mannitol was expressed as a provocative dose causing a 15% fall in FEV(1) (PD(15) ) and the response-dose ratio (RDR) (% fall in FEV(1) /cumulative dose). In 18 subjects who were deemed to have mannitol refractoriness in Phase 1, a mannitol challenge was performed before and after a methacholine challenge (Phase 2). In Phase 1, the time taken for the FEV(1) to recover after the first mannitol challenge ranged from 20 to 100 min with a median of 50 min. In the 23 subjects with a measurable mannitol PD(15) in both challenges, the geometric mean (95%CI) PD(15) in the second challenge (163 mg [114-232]) was significantly higher than that in the first challenge (66 mg [50-88], P < 0.001). The geometric mean (95%CI) RDR decreased from the value of 0.083%/mg (0.055-0.125) in the first challenge to 0.029%/mg (0.017-0.048) in the second challenge (P < 0.001). In Phase 2, prior challenge with methacholine or mannitol did not significantly alter subsequent bronchoconstriction to the opposite challenge. Repeated challenge with mannitol resulted in less bronchoconstriction when compared with the initial challenge. This refractoriness seems not to be attributable to functional loss of responsiveness or non-specific effect of prior bronchoconstriction.