Periodicity of monoisotopic mass isomers and isobars in proteomics

We report trends in the theoretically derived number of compositionally distinct peptides (i.e., peptides made up of different amino acid residues) up to a nominal mass of 1000. A total of 21 amino acid residues commonly found in proteomics studies are included in this study, 19 natural, nonisomeric amino acid residues as well as oxidated methione and acetamidated cysteine. The number of possibilities is found to increase in an exponential fashion with increasing nominal mass, and the data show a periodic oscillation that starts at mass ~200 and continues throughout to 1000. Note that similar effects are reported in the companion article on fragment ions from electron capture/transfer dissociation (ECD/ETD) (Mao et al. Anal. Chem.2011, DOI: 10.1021/ac201619t). The spacing of this oscillation is ~15 mass units at lower masses and ~14 mass units at higher nominal masses. This correlates with the most common mass differences between the amino acid building blocks. In other words, some mass differences are more common than others, thus determining the periodicity in this data. From an analytical point of view, nominal masses with a larger number of compositionally distinct peptides include a substantial number of isomers, which cannot be separated based on mass. Consequently, even ultrahigh mass accuracy (i.e., 0.5 ppm) does not lead to a substantially enhanced rate of identification. Conversely, for adjacent nominal masses with a lower number of isomers, moderately accurate mass (i.e., 10 ppm) gives a higher degree of certainty in identification. These effects are limited to the mass range between 200 and 500 Da. At higher masses, the percentage of uniquely identified peptides drops off to close to zero, independent of nominal mass, due the inherently high number of isomers. While the exact number of isobars/isomers at each nominal mass depends on the amino acid building blocks that are considered, the periodicity in the data is found to be remarkably robust; for instance, inclusion of phosphorylated residues barely affects the pattern at lower masses (i.e., <500 Da).