Automated hearing tests: applying the otogram to patients who are difficult to test

The Otogram is an automated audiometer capable of determining air and bone conduction thresholds with masking when appropriate. The manufacturer claims that testing can be done in a quiet physician's consultation room without a sound-treated booth. We aimed to test the validity of the Otogram on "difficult-to-test" patients, all of whom require masking.

Twenty-eight difficult-to-test patients underwent three audiograms: two by an audiologist and one by the Otogram. First, audiograms performed by the audiologists were compared, establishing test-retest reliability. Second, audiograms performed by the Otogram were compared to those of the audiologists. We calculated the percentage of pure-tone thresholds that were in agreement by 10 dB. Weighted kappa statistical analyses demonstrated levels of agreement.

Comparisons between audiologists demonstrated a very high degree of agreement. More than 90% of air and bone conduction thresholds fell within 10 dB of each other. Comparisons between audiologists and the Otogram also demonstrated a high degree of agreement.

The Otogram has the capability to accurately ascertain air and bone conduction thresholds. It appropriately used masking when indicated. The Otogram has great potential as a diagnostic tool to improve access to health care, especially where hearing test facilities are limited or unavailable.