Related Experiment Video
Updated: May 5, 2026
The Use of Mixed Reality in Custom-Made Revision Hip Arthroplasty: A First Case Report
Published on: August 4, 2022
Christiansen's artificial hip joints--what went wrong?
Insights
Norwegian surgeon Tor Aas Christiansen developed hip prostheses, but they were less successful than John Charnley's. A comparative study in 1983 led to the establishment of Norway's National Arthroplasty Register.
Area of Science:
- Orthopaedic Surgery
- Medical History
Background:
- Tor Aas Christiansen developed hip hemiprostheses and total prostheses in Norway during the 1960s to treat femoral neck fractures.
- Approximately 6,500 Christiansen prostheses were implanted in Norway before comparative studies demonstrated their limitations.
Discussion:
- The development of Christiansen's prostheses is a significant, though less recognized, part of hip arthroplasty history.
- A prospective study comparing Charnley and Christiansen prostheses in 1983 ultimately led to the discontinuation of Christiansen's designs in Norway.
Key Insights:
- Christiansen's prostheses, while ultimately unsuccessful, played a role in the evolution of hip arthroplasty.
- The comparative study's findings were instrumental in improving future hip replacement outcomes.
- This historical account highlights the iterative nature of medical device development and clinical evaluation.
Outlook:
- The study indirectly led to the creation of the National Arthroplasty Register in Norway, enhancing long-term patient outcome monitoring.
- Understanding historical prosthesis development provides valuable context for contemporary orthopaedic surgery.
- Further research into historical implant designs can inform future innovations in joint replacement surgery.
Abstract:
Modern arthroplasty is undoubtedly the greatest contribution that orthopaedic surgery has ever made to medical science. The honour for the good results achieved with total hip replacement surgery goes chiefly to the Briton John Charnley (1911-1982). However, the Norwegian Tor Aas Christiansen (1917-1981) has also earned a place in this history. He wanted to improve the operative treatment of dislocated, medial fractures of the femoral neck, and in the 1960s he constructed a hemiprosthesis. Later, he also made a total prosthesis for the hip joint. Over time, the prostheses proved to be less than successful. Nevertheless, approximately 6,500 Christiansen prostheses were fitted in Norway before a prospective Charnley vs. Christiansen study at the Coastal Hospital in Hagavik finally put an end to his prostheses in 1983. Indirectly, the study led to the establishment of a national register of hip prostheses, now the National Arthroplasty Register, at Haukeland University Hospital. Based on our personal cooperation with Christiansen, as well as original drawings and correspondence from the Polaris factory in Sandnes, we will tell the story of Christiansen's hemi- and total prostheses. These are a key element in the history of hip arthroplasty in Norway.
