Surgery in the HPV era: the role of robotics and microsurgical techniques

Retrospective studies suggested that head and neck cancers associated with human papilloma virus (HPV) are more frequently cured than those caused by substance use. The Eastern Cooperative Oncology Group (ECOG) subsequently confirmed the observation in a prospective trial. Most HPV-initiated cancers arise in the oropharynx. Survival differences between patients with cancers caused by HPV and those caused by alcohol and tobacco use persist despite modern treatment. The impression that treatment intensification has resulted in improved survivorship may well be attributable to an increasing proportion of patients with cancers caused by HPV infection. Unsatisfactory results for cancers attributable to substance use and encouraging improvements in tumor control for patients with HPV-initiated cancers have led to dissatisfaction with the current nonsurgical management paradigm. Ongoing advances in surgical techniques permit transoral resection of oropharyngeal cancers, thus limiting exposure-related morbidity and permitting ready recovery in terms of speech and swallowing. Transoral laser microsurgery (TLM) is increasingly employed and transoral robotic surgery (TORS) has dramatically popularized surgical treatment of oropharyngeal cancers. Resection affords the opportunity to increase local control at the primary site and surgical management of neck allows risk-based stratification of postoperative radiation therapy. Case series from several institutions show encouraging results. Transoral surgical resection is safe, can be undertaken with acceptable morbidity, and provides comparable locoregional control to that achieved with chemoradiation. Prospective trials for patients with HPV-initiated cancers, as well as those referable to substance use, are underway.